Seeking advice on Reddit, a 35-year-old woman shared her predicament. In her family, it is customary to pass down an emerald necklace to the oldest daughter or son on their 14th birthday. Her own daughter, Emily, is eagerly awaiting her upcoming 14th birthday in January 2024, when she is expected to receive this special heirloom.

The woman has been married to her husband Joey for two years. They both have daughters from previous relationships. Despite Joey’s knowledge of the family tradition and the woman’s intention to give the necklace to Emily, he made a surprising suggestion during a Christmas gift discussion.

Joey proposed that his own daughter, Sophia, should be the recipient of the emerald jewelry instead. He believed that giving Sophia the necklace would symbolize the woman’s acceptance of Sophia as her own daughter. Uncomfortable with this idea, the woman explained that Emily was already aware of the family tradition and was excited about receiving the necklace.

However, Joey remained stubborn and accused his wife of favoritism, suggesting that Emily could easily get another necklace from Amazon. Undeterred, the woman stood her ground, firmly stating that the family heirloom would go to Emily, regardless of Joey’s opinion. This decision led to Joey giving her the silent treatment, except when the children were present.

To make matters worse, Joey escalated the situation by sharing it with his mother and sister. They also accused the woman of favoritism and supported Joey’s belief that the necklace should go to Sophia. Feeling the strain on her marriage, the woman turned to Reddit for opinions, and the response was overwhelmingly in her favor.

Many internet users supported the woman’s decision. They emphasized that she was not favoring one child over another and that the necklace rightfully belonged to Emily. Some even suggested that she keep the necklace in a safe place to ensure it doesn’t disappear or get damaged.

Given this situation, what are your thoughts? Would you have made the same decision as this woman? Let us know in the comments!