Kelly Ripa and Mark Consuelos were only supposed to be reacting to a simple news item:

Girl Scouts discontinuing two flavors, S’mores and Toast-Yay, after the 2025 season.

Mark immediately braced for disaster, threatening to walk off set if his beloved Samoa was on the chopping block.

When he learned it was safe, the mood stayed playful—until Kelly casually admitted she’d never even heard of the outgoing “fan favorites.”

Trying to narrow down which flavors she actually liked, Mark tossed out the most iconic name of all:

Thin Mints. Kelly’s response was blunt and unfiltered—she doesn’t like them.

In a heartbeat, the studio audience turned, booing her on her own show over a cookie opinion.

Kelly stood her ground, laughing through the backlash, while Mark played the stunned traditionalist,

perfectly capturing a tiny cultural war waged over something as small, and revealing, as a box of cookies.